Skip to content

Car comparison

Smart #5 vs Tesla Model Y

A head-to-head comparison with real data from the Portuguese market: average price by registration year, fuel cost, depreciation and available supply.

First car
Second car

Smart

#5

€52,375

Average price
Registered 2025–2026

10 listings for sale

Tesla

Model Y

€36,116

Average price
Registered 2021–2026

633 listings for sale

carVerticalPartnerCar history: recorded mileage, accidents and damage, when available. 20% off with the code ENCONTRACARROS. Our link applies the discount for you.

The Tesla Model Y wins 2 of 2 categories

A summary of the head-to-head with the latest market data.

Smart #5Tesla Model Y
  • Smart #5: €52,375

    Cheaper to buy

    Average price of recent listings

    Tesla Model Y: €36,116
  • Smart #5: 10 listings

    More choice on the market

    Listings available now, in the chosen years

    Tesla Model Y: 633 listings

Fuel cost

Based on the average advertised consumption and current average fuel prices in Portugal, at 15,000 km a year.

TeslaTesla Model Y

€1.21per 100 km

Estimated annual cost (15,000 km)
€181
Most common fuel
Electric
Average advertised consumption
5.5 kWh/100 km
Price we used (reference household tariff)
€0.220/kWh

No consumption data for the Smart #5, so it cannot be compared.

Estimates based on the average consumption in each model's listings and the latest national average fuel prices (DGEG data, the Portuguese energy authority). For electric cars we use a reference household tariff of €0.22/kWh. See the current fuel prices.

Price trend

Average listing price of each model, month by month, over the last year.

Average price over the last 12 months

Based on 29 Smart #5 listings and 3,032 Tesla Model Y listings (Smart #5: registered 2025–2026; Tesla Model Y: registered 2021–2026).

Side-by-side specs

Every market indicator for both models, side by side.

Market indicators for the Smart #5 and the Tesla Model Y
IndicatorSmart #5Registered 2025–2026Tesla Model YRegistered 2021–2026
Average price (recent listings)€52,375€36,116
Available listings10633
Sold listings192,399
Cars analysed293,032
Time to sellNo dataUnder 1 month
Estimated annual depreciationNo data≈ 5.8%
Overall market share0.00%0.47%
Average power468 hp419 hp
Most common fuelElectricElectric
Average advertised consumptionNo data5.5 kWh/100 km
Body typeNo dataSUV/4x4

Supply by district

Where each model was listed over the last 12 months.

SmartSmart #5Registered 2025–2026
Viana do CasteloBragaPortoVila RealBragançaGuardaViseuAveiroCoimbraCastelo BrancoLeiriaLisbonSantarémPortalegreÉvoraBejaFaroSetúbalAzoresMadeira
TeslaTesla Model YRegistered 2021–2026
Viana do CasteloBragaPortoVila RealBragançaGuardaViseuAveiroCoimbraCastelo BrancoLeiriaLisbonSantarémPortalegreÉvoraBejaFaroSetúbalAzoresMadeira
Listings by district for the Smart #5 and the Tesla Model Y
DistrictSmart #5Tesla Model Y
Braga2554
Lisbon4546
Porto10513
Santarém0353
Setúbal0307
Aveiro0240
Viana do Castelo1228
Leiria086
Faro265
Viseu052
Castelo Branco021
Vila Real014

Tap a number to see those listings. We show the 12 districts with the most supply.

Frequently asked questions

The most common questions about the Smart #5 vs the Tesla Model Y, answered with market data.

Which is cheaper: the Smart #5 or the Tesla Model Y?

On average, the Tesla Model Y is cheaper: it costs about €36,116 (registered between 2021 and 2026), while the Smart #5 costs €52,375 on average (registered between 2025 and 2026). The difference is around €16,259, based on used car listings published on the main Portuguese platforms over the last 12 months.

How much does a used Smart #5 cost in Portugal?

A used Smart #5 costs €52,375 on average in Portugal, based on listings registered between 2025 and 2026. The price varies with the registration year, the mileage and the version. Right now there are 10 listings for this model in Portugal.

How much does a used Tesla Model Y cost in Portugal?

A used Tesla Model Y costs €36,116 on average in Portugal, based on listings registered between 2021 and 2026. The price varies with the registration year, the mileage and the version. Right now there are 633 listings for this model in Portugal.

How many Smart #5 and Tesla Model Y listings are there in Portugal?

Right now there are 10 Smart #5 listings and 633 Tesla Model Y listings on the main used car sites in Portugal. These figures are updated daily.

Which is more powerful: the Smart #5 or the Tesla Model Y?

On average, Smart #5 cars listed in Portugal have 468 hp and Tesla Model Y cars 419 hp, so the Smart #5 is, on average, the more powerful. Power varies a lot with the engine and the version.

Smart #5 listings

Tesla Model Y listings

Other comparisons

These models head to head with their direct rivals.

All comparisons

Each of these models head to head with every rival on the Portuguese market.

Want to compare other models? Use the car comparison tool or see the comparisons for every model.

Cookie policy

With your permission, we use analytics cookies (Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity). If you reject them, we only use the essential ones and count visits without cookies. Find out more in our Privacy Policy.